THE PROBLEM ISN’T THAT I ASK QUESTIONS. IT’S THAT WE’VE STOPPED ASKING THEM.

By Joshua L Mullins

When an Analytical Mind Meets Biblical Discernment—and the Danger of Believing Everything You’re Told

I’ve had people tell me over the years that I have an analytical mind.

And sometimes, judging by the way they said it, I wasn’t sure whether they were complimenting me or telling me I had a problem.

Apparently, I ask too many questions.

I want to know why something is true. I want to know where the information came from. And when something doesn’t add up, I have a difficult time pretending that it does.

But here’s what I want to know.

Since when did asking questions become a character flaw?

If someone stands behind a pulpit and tells me what the Bible teaches, am I supposed to believe it simply because he’s a minister?

If a historian tells me what happened 300 years ago, am I supposed to accept it because his name appears on a textbook?

If a politician makes a promise, am I supposed to believe it because we belong to the same political party?

Come on.

There’s a difference between respecting someone’s position and surrendering your ability to think.

And I believe we’ve confused those two things for far too long.

Solomon Had Something to Say About This

Proverbs 14:15 says:

“The simple believeth every word: but the prudent man looketh well to his going.” — KJV

Read that carefully.

The simple believes every word.

Not the wise man. Not the discerning man. Not the person exercising good judgment.

The simple.

The Hebrew word translated simple describes someone inexperienced or easily persuaded. Solomon is contrasting that person with someone who exercises caution and considers what he’s being told.

Now ask yourself something.

How many things have we believed throughout our lives simply because someone we trusted said they were true?

We heard it growing up. Our parents heard it from their parents. Somebody taught it in Sunday school. A preacher repeated it. A teacher explained it.

And eventually, we stopped asking where it came from.

It became familiar.

And somewhere along the way, familiarity began taking the place of verification.

That’s a dangerous exchange.

Because hearing something repeatedly doesn’t make it true.

There’s Actually Research Behind That

In 1977, psychologists Lynn Hasher, David Goldstein, and Thomas Toppino published a study examining how repetition influences people’s judgments about whether statements are true.

Participants evaluated statements over several sessions. The researchers found that repeated statements tended to receive higher truth ratings, even when the statements themselves had not changed.

Psychologists call this the illusory truth effect.

And this isn’t based on one forgotten experiment.

A systematic review published in Nature Communications on February 27, 2026, examined 182 studies involving 31,184 participants.

The researchers found that repetition had a measurable, though generally modest, effect on how truthful information appeared.

Think about the implications.

A statement doesn’t necessarily need additional evidence to begin feeling more believable.

Sometimes people become more comfortable with it simply because they’ve encountered it before.

Does that mean everyone automatically believes a repeated lie? No.

But it does mean we should be careful about confusing something we’ve heard a hundred times with something we’ve actually investigated.

Now bring that into everyday life.

How many religious traditions have been repeated for generations?

How many historical claims have been passed down without anybody examining the original documents?

How many opinions have we heard so often that we defend them without even remembering where we first learned them?

And here’s the uncomfortable question.

Are we defending the truth, or are we defending what we’ve become accustomed to believing?

Those aren’t necessarily the same thing.

Even the Apostle Paul Was Examined

Acts 17 tells us about Paul and Silas arriving in Berea.

They entered the synagogue and began teaching.

Now, remember who we’re talking about.

Paul wasn’t some inexperienced speaker who wandered into town with a handful of opinions.

He was an apostle preaching Jesus Christ.

Yet notice what Scripture says about the people who heard him.

Acts 17:11:

“These were more noble than those in Thessalonica, in that they received the word with all readiness of mind, and searched the scriptures daily, whether those things were so.” — KJV

Did you catch that?

They received the message willingly.

But they also searched the Scriptures.

They didn’t confuse the authority of the speaker with the truth of the message.

And Scripture calls them noble for doing it.

Now imagine someone doing that in a church today.

A minister teaches something, and afterward a person asks, “Pastor, can you show me where Scripture teaches that?”

That shouldn’t be an insult.

That should be an opportunity to open the Bible together.

If something is genuinely taught in Scripture, why would examining the passage be a problem?

I graduated from Bible school, and I’ve spent years studying and teaching God’s Word. But that doesn’t place my understanding above examination either.

God’s Word is the authority. The person explaining it isn’t.

And yes, that includes me.

Charles Spurgeon Wasn’t Afraid of Questions Either

On June 21, 1866, Charles Spurgeon preached a sermon called How to Read the Bible at the Metropolitan Tabernacle in London.

Spurgeon challenged Christians to examine what they heard, professed, and read.

He specifically warned against accepting a religious teaching simply because of admiration for the minister delivering it.

Think about that.

One of the most influential Baptist preachers in history was telling Christians not to surrender their judgment to a preacher’s reputation.

And his reasoning was grounded in Scripture.

That’s an important lesson for the Church.

We have Baptists, Methodists, Pentecostals, Presbyterians, Lutherans, and numerous other Christian denominations.

They sometimes reach different conclusions about baptism, spiritual gifts, salvation, church government, and other doctrines.

Those differences didn’t create multiple Bibles.

They reveal that people can approach the same biblical text with different traditions, assumptions, and methods of interpretation.

The existence of a disagreement doesn’t automatically tell us which interpretation is correct.

But it certainly gives us a reason to study.

If I inherit a teaching from my denomination, I want to know what Scripture says.

If another denomination disagrees, I want to understand which passages they’re using and how they’re interpreting them.

Not because I believe every doctrine is equally true.

But because I believe God’s Word deserves more than my loyalty to a religious label.

Analytical Doesn’t Mean You’re Always Right

Now let me address something about being analytical.

An analytical person can ask good questions and still reach a wrong conclusion.

It’s possible to examine evidence and misunderstand it.

It’s possible to become so suspicious that you reject something before you’ve given it a fair hearing.

And it’s possible to become so determined to prove someone wrong that you overlook the evidence proving them right.

I’ve had to recognize that distinction myself.

The purpose of examining something shouldn’t be to win every argument.

It should be to discover what’s true.

And if the truth proves that something I’ve believed for years was incorrect, I need to have enough humility to acknowledge it.

That’s not abandoning conviction.

That’s refusing to make my own opinion the final authority.

Proverbs 18:13 says:

“He that answereth a matter before he heareth it, it is folly and shame unto him.” — KJV

That verse applies to people who believe everything without checking.

But it also applies to people who dismiss everything without listening.

Biblical discernment requires both courage and humility.

The courage to question.

And the humility to receive a truthful answer, even when it isn’t the answer we expected.

I Don’t Want Secondhand Convictions

Here’s what concerns me.

It’s possible to spend your entire life defending something you never personally examined.

You can inherit a political position.

You can inherit a religious tradition.

You can inherit somebody else’s interpretation of history.

And none of those things automatically become true because they’re part of your upbringing.

That doesn’t mean our parents, grandparents, pastors, or teachers were intentionally misleading us.

Many faithfully passed along what they genuinely believed.

But sincerity isn’t a substitute for accuracy.

I believe the Bible is the Word of God. I believe Jesus Christ is Lord. Those are foundational convictions in my life.

And because I take those convictions seriously, I want to understand what the Bible actually teaches.

Not merely what somebody told me it teaches.

Not what a particular denomination has always taught.

Not what sounds good from behind a pulpit.

What does the Scripture say, in its proper context?

The same principle applies when I study history.

I want the original records. I want to understand the circumstances. I want to know where an interpretation came from.

Because if something is worth believing, it’s worth examining.

And if someone claims to possess the truth, asking them to explain the evidence shouldn’t be treated as an act of rebellion.

So, Am I Too Analytical?

Maybe I do ask more questions than some people are comfortable answering.

Maybe I take longer to accept a conclusion because I want to understand how somebody arrived at it.

And maybe there have been times when I’ve questioned something that turned out to be right all along.

I’m willing to live with that.

But I’m not willing to pretend I understand something simply because everybody around me seems satisfied with the explanation.

I’m not interested in becoming the kind of person who believes everything.

And I’m not interested in becoming the kind of person who believes nothing.

I want to be the kind of person who knows why he believes what he believes.

That’s the difference.

And I think we need more of that in our churches, our schools, our communities, and our conversations.

People willing to ask a question without being disrespectful.

People willing to examine evidence without being afraid of where it leads.

People willing to acknowledge when they’re wrong.

And people who understand that genuine faith and honest investigation don’t have to be enemies.

So the next time somebody tells me I have an analytical mind, I won’t automatically assume they mean it as a criticism.

I’ll simply remember what Solomon said.

The simple believes every word.

The prudent considers his steps.

And I’ll remember Paul’s instruction in 1 Thessalonians 5:21:

“Prove all things; hold fast that which is good.” — KJV

That’s the standard I want to live by.

Not believing everything.

Not rejecting everything.

Examining what I hear, holding on to what is true, and having the courage to change my mind when the evidence requires it.

Because the problem isn’t that I ask questions.

The problem begins when we stop asking them.


Sources and Documentation

1. The Holy Bible, King James Version

Proverbs 14:15; Proverbs 18:13; Acts 17:10–11; 1 Thessalonians 5:21.

2. Hasher, Lynn; Goldstein, David; and Toppino, Thomas (1977).

Frequency and the Conference of Referential Validity. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 16(1), 107–112.

3. Ye, Steeven, and colleagues (February 27, 2026).

Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of the Evidence for an Illusory Truth Effect and Its Determinants. Nature Communications, 17, article 3270.

4. Charles H. Spurgeon (June 21, 1866).

How to Read the Bible. Sermon delivered at the Metropolitan Tabernacle, Newington, London. Published September 5, 1912, in The Metropolitan Tabernacle Pulpit, Volume 58.

Leave a Reply