WHO WROTE THE HISTORY WE WERE TAUGHT?

By Joshua L Mullins

The Events Didn’t Change. So Who Decided to Change the Story?

I want to ask you something, and I want you to seriously think about it.

What if I told you that people have been deliberately influencing what American children learn about history for well over a hundred years?

Not a theory. Not some conspiracy somebody cooked up on the internet. I’m talking about actual documents. Names. Dates. Government records. Instructions telling educators which history books should be accepted and which should be rejected.

And here’s the part that ought to get your attention.

Some of the people responsible weren’t trying to discover what happened. They were trying to determine which version of what happened would be taught.

Don’t believe me?

Let’s go back to 1919.

A woman named Mildred Lewis Rutherford, a historian for the United Daughters of the Confederacy, prepared a publication called A Measuring Rod to Test Text Books, and Reference Books in Schools, Colleges and Libraries.

Sounds innocent enough, doesn’t it?

Except it wasn’t simply a book about history.

It was a guide intended to influence which historical materials schools and libraries accepted.

And listen to one of her instructions:

“Reject a book that says the South fought to hold her slaves.”

There it is.

Right there in black and white.

You can read the original document today. The Library of Congress has preserved it, and the Valentine Museum has published a copy for historical education.

Now explain something to me.

Why would someone instruct educators to reject a history book based on whether it acknowledges slavery as a cause of the Civil War?

Shouldn’t we examine what the Confederate states actually said about their reasons for secession?

Shouldn’t we investigate their own declarations, speeches, and political documents?

Or are we supposed to disregard evidence because it doesn’t fit somebody’s preferred account?

And before you think this was one woman’s private opinion that nobody took seriously, understand something.

Rutherford prepared her publication at the request of the United Confederate Veterans. Her work was connected to an organized campaign to influence historical instruction.

The Valentine Museum documents how those efforts shaped textbook selection and historical teaching for decades.

That’s not speculation about somebody’s motives today. That’s a documented campaign from the past.

And it raises a question that every American ought to care about.

If people could organize campaigns to shape what children learned in 1919, why would we assume political influence over historical education is impossible today?

They Didn’t Even Have to Change the Facts. They Could Leave Them Out.

Now go back another forty-six years.

In 1873, Mary Tucker Magill published a textbook titled History of Virginia, For the Use of Schools.

  1. 1873.

The Civil War had ended just eight years earlier.

Abraham Lincoln had been assassinated.

Slavery had been abolished under the Thirteenth Amendment.

The entire country was dealing with the consequences of a conflict that had torn families, communities, and states apart.

And Virginia had been at the very center of that war.

So wouldn’t you expect a Virginia history textbook to explain what happened?

Well, here’s the problem.

Magill’s historical narrative ended with John Brown’s raid on Harpers Ferry in 1859.

The Civil War wasn’t covered.

Reconstruction wasn’t covered.

Nothing about those subsequent years was included in that account.

The Library of Virginia documents this omission, and the original 1873 book survives in the Library of Congress.

Now, I’m not going to invent a private conversation that Magill might have had or pretend I know every reason she made that editorial decision.

I don’t need to.

The omission is documented.

And that’s what makes this so important.

Imagine a student depending on that textbook to understand Virginia’s history.

How could that child learn about the Civil War from a book that stops before the Civil War?

How could that child understand Reconstruction when the book doesn’t cover Reconstruction?

And how could that student recognize what was missing if nobody ever told them?

You see where I’m going?

Historical information doesn’t have to be fabricated to create a misleading account.

Sometimes important information can simply be excluded.

And if you never know what was left out, you may go through life believing you’ve received the complete story.

That’s a serious problem.

Then the Government Got Involved.

Now fast-forward to February 8, 1950.

The Virginia Senate approved a resolution establishing a commission to oversee the writing and publication of textbooks on Virginia history, government, and geography.

The measure was Senate Joint Resolution No. 5.

It passed by a vote of twenty-five to six.

Twenty-five to six.

The original legislative record survives.

The commission was authorized to select writers, arrange manuscript reviews, and prepare books for possible adoption in public schools.

That’s a government body helping determine how children would learn the history of their own state.

And what happened?

The fourth-grade textbook entered Virginia classrooms in 1956. Additional books for seventh-grade and high-school students followed in 1957.

According to Encyclopedia Virginia, the resulting textbooks promoted the Lost Cause interpretation of Southern history.

One seventh-grade book even described the lives of enslaved Black Virginians as generally happy.

Happy?

We’re talking about human beings who were legally held as property, denied fundamental freedoms, and subjected to a system that permitted their forced labor.

And children were being given a historical account that portrayed that system favorably.

That wasn’t some statement overheard in a private conversation.

It appeared in an approved school textbook.

And here’s something else worth knowing.

Not everybody accepted it.

Black educators and civil rights organizations challenged the textbooks. Some white educators and lawmakers also opposed the commission’s approach. The Virginia NAACP protested the historical material.

So there were people questioning these narratives at the time.

But the books still reached classrooms.

An official textbook can carry an official approval and still teach a seriously misleading version of history.

That should be enough to make us examine the process, regardless of which political party controls it.

Because government approval is not proof of historical accuracy.

And I don’t care how prestigious the committee is.

Show me the evidence.

A Ninth-Grade Student Had to Catch the Mistake.

You want something more recent?

October 2015.

A Texas ninth-grader named Coby Burren was reading a McGraw-Hill geography textbook when he encountered a caption about the Atlantic slave trade.

The wording described Africans brought to America as workers.

Workers?

Those people weren’t simply applying for jobs. They were forcibly transported and enslaved.

Coby showed the passage to his mother, Roni Dean-Burren. She publicly challenged it, and the controversy attracted national attention.

Eventually, McGraw-Hill acknowledged that the language failed to explain the forced nature of the migration and labor.

The company agreed to correct it.

Now, somebody explain that to me.

This was a major educational publisher.

The material had passed through a review process.

The book had reached students.

And a teenager identified a problem serious enough that the publisher admitted a correction was necessary.

How does that happen?

And how many students would have read that description without questioning it?

Here’s what makes this even more revealing.

In November 2015, the Texas State Board of Education narrowly rejected a proposal that would have allowed it to create a dedicated expert panel for identifying textbook errors.

That was reported by The Texas Tribune.

Think about the disagreement.

A textbook controversy had exposed a serious mistake. The publisher acknowledged it. Yet education officials still disagreed over how to improve the review process.

Now, I understand that committees don’t automatically solve every problem.

But shouldn’t we be demanding an effective process for checking what gets put into our children’s textbooks?

Why should a parent have to discover the mistake after the book is already in the classroom?

And why should anyone be offended when parents ask for documentation?

We’re talking about their children’s education.

Same America. Different History.

Now let’s move to January 12, 2020.

The New York Times published an investigation by Dana Goldstein titled Two States. Eight Textbooks. Two American Stories.

Eight history textbooks.

Two states.

California and Texas.

Same country. Same Constitution. Same historical events.

And investigators found hundreds of differences between the books.

Some were small. Others were substantial.

The differences involved subjects including immigration, economics, constitutional rights, and American social history.

Here’s what really gets my attention.

Some of these books came from the same publishing companies and credited the same authors.

So why were the contents different?

Because textbook publishers adapted material for different state educational requirements and priorities.

Now I’m not saying every difference was false. Some changes may have provided useful information that another edition lacked.

But why shouldn’t the public examine the differences?

If one edition adds an explanation of a constitutional ruling and another leaves it out, shouldn’t we know why?

If one state requires a particular historical emphasis and another state requires something different, shouldn’t parents understand those decisions?

Because those differences influence what students encounter.

And here’s the question that matters.

Are we selecting historical material because the evidence supports it, or because the people approving it prefer a particular interpretation?

Sometimes the answer may be both.

But that is exactly why the process deserves scrutiny.

History isn’t supposed to be a political prize awarded to whichever side controls the textbook committee.

I’m Tired of Being Told Not to Question the Experts.

Let me tell you where I stand.

I have nothing against historians doing their jobs. I have nothing against teachers who genuinely want children to understand history. And I have nothing against correcting old textbooks when new evidence shows they were wrong.

But I do have a problem with the idea that an official explanation should be accepted without examination.

Why?

Because we just looked at more than a century of documented examples.

In 1873, a history textbook omitted the Civil War.

Around 1919, an organized movement produced instructions for rejecting historical books that contradicted its preferred narrative.

In 1950, Virginia established a government commission that went on to produce textbooks containing seriously misleading accounts.

In 2015, a ninth-grade student uncovered misleading wording in an approved textbook.

And in 2020, investigators documented hundreds of differences in textbooks prepared for two American states.

These aren’t five stories I invented to make a point.

The records exist.

The documents can be examined.

And they demonstrate that historical education is influenced by the decisions of human beings and institutions.

People with convictions.

People with political beliefs.

People who make mistakes.

And sometimes people who actively attempt to control the historical narrative.

That should concern us.

But here’s something else I want to make clear.

If a historian corrects a false account from fifty years ago, that isn’t necessarily rewriting history.

That may be exactly what historical research is supposed to accomplish.

The problem isn’t that textbooks change.

The problem is when a historical account is shaped by something other than the best available evidence—and readers aren’t given a fair way to recognize it.

I Want My Children to Know the Difference.

I’m a Christian. I’m an American. And I care about what kind of country my children and grandchildren are going to inherit.

I want them to know the Constitution.

I want them to understand our founding documents.

I want them to know what earlier generations accomplished, what they got wrong, and what those experiences can teach us.

But I don’t want them accepting an account simply because it came from a government-approved book.

And I don’t want them rejecting accurate information simply because it challenges something their parents or grandparents were taught.

I want them to learn how to examine it.

The Bible says in Proverbs 18:17:

“He that is first in his own cause seemeth just; but his neighbour cometh and searcheth him.” — KJV

That’s a principle worth remembering.

Just because somebody presents an argument convincingly doesn’t mean they’ve presented the entire matter.

You examine it.

You ask questions.

You check the evidence.

And if you discover something was wrong, you correct it.

That’s how responsible people should approach history.

So Here’s My Challenge.

If you still have one of your old schoolbooks, pull it out.

Find a history textbook your parents or grandparents used.

Compare it with one students are using today.

Don’t just look for what changed.

Ask why it changed.

Was there new evidence?

Was an error corrected?

Was important information added?

Or did somebody change the presentation without establishing a sound historical reason?

And when you find a discrepancy, don’t immediately assume the old book is right or the new book is wrong.

Go to the original records.

That’s where the investigation begins.

I believe we should demand historical honesty from every institution responsible for educating the next generation.

That means publishers.

School boards.

State officials.

Historians.

And anybody else presenting a historical claim as established fact.

Nobody should receive a free pass.

Not because they’re Republican.

Not because they’re Democrat.

Not because they’re conservative.

Not because they’re progressive.

And certainly not because they have a university degree or a government title.

If you’re going to teach our children that something happened, be prepared to show them the evidence.

That’s not an unreasonable demand.

That’s what an education built on truth should require.

Because the next generation shouldn’t have to spend half its adult life trying to figure out which parts of its history education were accurate and which parts were somebody else’s preferred interpretation.

The events of the past cannot be changed.

But the way those events are presented can be.

We’ve seen it in the records.

And now that we know it has happened, we have every reason to pay attention.

So here’s the question I want to leave you with:

If somebody can decide what parts of history your children learn, what parts they never encounter, and how those events are explained, shouldn’t you know who made those decisions—and why?

I think you should.

And I think it’s long past time we started asking.


Historical Documents and Sources

1. Mildred Lewis Rutherford, A Measuring Rod to Test Text Books (1919–1920). Original historical publication preserved by the Library of Congress and the Digital Library of Georgia.

2. The Valentine Museum, A Measuring Rod by Mildred L. Rutherford, 1919. Historical context and reproduced primary-source excerpts.

3. Mary Tucker Magill, History of Virginia, For the Use of Schools (1873). Original textbook, Library of Congress.

4. Library of Virginia, Myth & Memory: Teaching and Reading Virginia History. Historical textbook omissions and subsequent educational controversies.

5. Virginia General Assembly, Senate Joint Resolution No. 5 (February 8, 1950). Original legislative record.

6. Encyclopedia Virginia, The Virginia History and Textbook Commission. Historical study of the commission, textbook contents, and opposition to those narratives.

7. The Texas Tribune, October 5 and November 18, 2015. Reporting on the McGraw-Hill textbook controversy and subsequent consideration of review reforms.

8. Dana Goldstein, Two States. Eight Textbooks. Two American Stories., The New York Times, January 12, 2020.

Scripture: Proverbs 18:17, King James Version.

Leave a Reply